|
Consciousness » Approaches
Cognitive neuroscience approaches:
Modern investigations into and discoveries about consciousness are based
on psychological statistical studies and case studies of consciousness
states and the deficits caused by lesions, stroke, injury, or surgery
that disrupt the normal functioning of human senses and cognition. These
discoveries suggest that the mind is a complex structure derived from
various localized functions that are bound together with a unitary awareness.
Several studies point to common mechanisms in different clinical conditions
that lead to loss of consciousness. Persistent vegetative state (PVS)
is a condition in which an individual loses the higher cerebral powers
of the brain, but maintains sleep-wake cycles with full or partial autonomic
functions. Studies comparing PVS with healthy, awake subjects consistently
demonstrate an impaired connectivity between the deeper (brainstem and
thalamic) and the upper (cortical) areas of the brain. In addition, it
is agreed that the general brain activity in the cortex is lower in the
PVS state. Some electroneurobiological interpretations of consciousness
characterize this loss of consciousness as a loss of the ability to resolve
time (similar to playing an old phonographic record at very slow or very
rapid speed), along a continuum that starts with inattention, continues
on sleep and arrives to coma and death.
Loss of consciousness also occurs in other conditions, such as general
(tonic-clonic) epileptic seizures, in general anaesthesia, maybe even
in deep (slow wave) sleep. The currently best supported hypotheses about
such cases of loss of consciousness (or loss of time resolution) focus
on the need for 1) a widespread cortical network, including particularly
the frontal, parietal and temporal cortices, and 2) cooperation between
the deep layers of the brain, especially the thalamus, and the upper layers;
the cortex. Such hypotheses go under the common term "globalist theories"
of consciousness, due to the claim for a widespread, global network necessary
for consciousness to interact with non-mental reality in the first place.
Brain chemistry affects human consciousness. Sleeping drugs (such as
Midazolam = Dormicum) can bring the brain from the awake condition (conscious)
to the sleep (unconscious). Wake-up drugs such as Anexate reverse this
process. Many other drugs (such as heroin, cocaine, LSD, MDMA) have a
consciousness-changing effect.
There is a neural link between the left and right hemispheres of the
brain, known as the corpus callosum. This link is sometimes surgically
severed to control severe seizures in epilepsy patients. Tests of these
patients have shown that after the link is completely severed, each hemisphere
possesses its own sense of self and each has a separate awareness from
the other. It is as if two separate minds now share the same skull, but
both still represent themselves as a single "I" to the outside
world.
The bilateral removal of the Centromedian nucleus (part of the Intra-laminar
nucleus of the Thalamus) appears to abolish consciousness, causing coma,
PVS, severe mutism and other features that mimic brain death. The centromedian
nucleus is also one of the principal sites of action of general anaesthetics
and anti-psychotic drugs.
Philosophical approaches:
Philosophers distinguish between phenomenal consciousness and access or
psychological consciousness. Some suggest that consciousness resists or
even defies definition. There are many philosophical stances on consciousness,
sometimes known as 'isms', including: behaviorism, cognitivism, dualism,
idealism, functionalism, phenomenalism, physicalism, pseudonomenalism,
emergentism, and mysticism.
Phenomenal and access consciousness:
Philosophers call our current experience phenomenal consciousness. Phenomenal
consciousness is simply experience, it is moving, coloured forms, sounds,
sensations, emotions and feelings with our bodies and responses at the
centre. The Hard problem of consciousness is how to explain a state of
phenomenal consciousness in terms of its neurological basis (Chalmers
1996). Some philosophers, such as Descartes in his famous phrase "cogito,
ergo sum", believe that phenomenal consciousness is incorrigible,
meaning that it cannot be doubted.
Access consciousness means something like awareness, or that a mind is
directed at something. (That sounds more like a definition of that philosophical
term "intentionality" often referred to with the layman's term
"aboutness".) So when we perceive, we are conscious of what
we perceive; when we introspect, we are conscious of our thoughts; when
we remember, we are conscious of something that happened in the past,
or of some piece of information that we learned; and so on. Naive and
Direct Realists believe that access consciousness is all that needs to
be known about consciousness because they regard phenomenal consciousness
as the world itself.
Events that occur in the mind or brain that are not within phenomenal
consciousness are known as unconscious events.
|